Saturday, July 6, 2013

Review: The Five Red Herrings

Five Red Herrings (Lord Peter Wimsey,  #7)Five Red Herrings by Dorothy L. Sayers

My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I always enjoy Sayers novels, but this one was not one of my favorites. The story centers around 6 artists, one of whom may be a murderer (the other 5 are the herrings), but they weren't distict enough characters to keep them sorted out amongst all the train schedules, bicycles, and painting tools. The solution to the mystery is handed to the reader when Lord Peter finds the body, but is buried among lots of distractions (herring anyone?) and is easily missed. When it was explained at the end I couldn't belive I missed something so obvious, but I did. 

The writing is very sharp and full of references and inside jokes for the observant reader. There is an entire section where everything Lord Peter says is dialog from MacBeth. I also love how Sayers pops in now and again with commentary on the detective novel form. 
"See here, Whimsey, you're not going to turn round now and say that the crime was committed by Mrs. Green or the milkmam, or somebody we've never heard of? That would be in the very worst tradition of the lowest style of detective fiction." (p.273)
This book, c1931, counts toward the Vintage Mystery Challenge in the category of Murder by the Numbers.


  1. I have yet to read one of her books. I think I'm going to start at the begining and work my way through them.

    1. I hope you enjoy them. The first one is quite good. I read them all about 20 years ago and decided a while back to re-read them in order. I wasn't paying close attention when I picked this one up though as it is #7 and I last read #3.

  2. I am reading these in order and haven't gotten to this one yet. I enjoy them for their wit even when the plots can be a little random.

    I'm also doing the Vintage Mystery Challenge. Glad I re-found your blog!

    Rose City Reader

    1. Thanks for stopping by! The plots can be a bit random, but Lord Peter always entertains me anyway. Which vintage mystery has been your favorite so far?


Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...